If you're a homeowner in Evanston, chances are you've faced the question: “Should I tackle this project myself or bring in a pro?” I hear this a lot from clients—especially when they’re preparing to sell or just moved into a new place. It’s tempting to go the DIY route to save money, but some projects really are better left to professionals. Knowing when to roll up your sleeves and when to call in expert help can save time, stress, and even money in the long run.
Let’s break down the real factors that should guide your decision—and what makes the most sense in our local market.
Key Takeaways
- DIY is great for simple, cosmetic projects with low risk
- Professional work can increase resale value and avoid costly mistakes
- Consider time, tools, permits, and safety when making your choice
- Some improvements are more marketable when done by licensed pros
The Case for Doing It Yourself
There’s something satisfying about fixing up your own home—especially when it’s a small, manageable project. DIY can work well when you're confident, the stakes are low, and the results don’t need to be flawless.
Best Projects To Tackle on Your Own
- Painting walls or trim: A fresh coat makes a big impact and is budget-friendly
- Updating cabinet hardware: Quick upgrade with minimal tools
- Installing shelves or organizing closets: Custom storage adds value
- Landscaping or yard cleanup: Boosts curb appeal without much investment
- Simple lighting or fixture swaps: As long as you're comfortable turning off the power
These are great weekend tasks for homes in neighborhoods like Aspen Grove or Willow Creek, where even small updates can boost appeal.
When It Pays To Hire a Contractor
While DIY may seem cheaper upfront, certain jobs demand professional expertise—especially when they affect safety, structure, or resale value. A botched job can end up costing more than hiring a pro from the start.
Projects Better Left to Professionals
- Plumbing or electrical upgrades: Mistakes here can be dangerous and expensive
- Roof repair or replacement: Risk of injury and long-term leaks
- Major kitchen or bath remodels: Involves plumbing, tiling, and precise work
- HVAC installation or repairs: Requires permits, testing, and experience
- Structural changes: Walls, foundations, or additions should never be DIY
In Evanston, buyers often expect professional quality in these areas—especially in high-value neighborhoods like Twin Ridge or Blackhawk Estates.
Consider the Time vs. Value Trade-Off
Your time has value too. Even a project that seems simple can spiral into weekends of trips to the hardware store, frustration, and do-overs.
Ask Yourself These Questions Before Starting DIY
- Do I have the tools and skills to do this safely?
- Will mistakes cost more than the project itself?
- Is my time better spent elsewhere right now?
- Will buyers or appraisers care if it’s not perfect?
- Does the project require a permit or inspection?
In many cases, hiring a contractor means it’s done faster, cleaner, and with documentation you can show to future buyers.
The Impact on Resale Value
This is where many of my clients make their final decision. DIY projects that are obviously homemade—or incomplete—can actually lower a home's appeal. Buyers notice uneven tile, off-level cabinets, or paint on the ceiling. If you're preparing to list your home in Evanston, quality matters more than effort.
What Buyers Prefer in Finished Homes
- Professionally remodeled kitchens and bathrooms
- Permitted and inspected structural work
- Code-compliant plumbing, HVAC, and electrical systems
- Even, consistent finishes and functional layouts
Appraisers also tend to give more weight to licensed improvements, especially in older homes common near the Union Center Historic District or Bear River Drive.
Cost Isn’t Always the Deciding Factor
While saving money matters, DIY isn’t always the cheaper route—especially if you have to redo the work or bring in help later. Get quotes from local contractors and compare with your time, tools, and potential for error.
When To Get a Professional Quote
- You’re prepping the home to list
- You’re upgrading core systems like HVAC or plumbing
- You’re short on time or confidence
- The project could affect the value or safety of your home
I often refer clients to trusted Evanston contractors when I know professional work will pay off, especially in today’s competitive market.
FAQs
Can I DIY improvements and still get good resale value?
Yes—for cosmetic updates like paint, landscaping, and basic hardware. For major systems or remodels, professional work adds more value and buyer confidence.
What if I already started a DIY project and got stuck?
You can still hire a contractor to finish the job, but be honest about what’s been done so they can evaluate what needs to be corrected or redone.
Are permits required for all professional work?
Not all, but many projects—especially electrical, HVAC, and structural changes—do require permits and inspections in Uinta County. A contractor can handle that for you.
Contact Britany Erickson Today
Thinking about upgrading your home before you sell? Or maybe you're weighing whether to DIY your next project or hire it out? I’d be happy to offer guidance based on what matters most in the Evanston market. The right decision can save you money and increase your home’s appeal.
Reach out to me,
Britany Erickson, and let’s talk about which projects make sense to do yourself—and which ones will add the most value when done professionally. I’m here to help you make smart, informed choices every step of the way.
*Header photo by Britany Erickson
