November 19, 2026
In early June 2004, a Wyoming Game and Fish crew from the Green River Region was gill netting Sulphur Creek Reservoir to check on its trout. They set two extra nets along the face of the dam to catch smallmouth bass, which had been illegally introduced and were first documented there in 2000. The extra nets caught no bass. They caught three walleye.
The crew came back in late June and netted 39 more, ranging from 6.6 to 17.1 inches and averaging 11.9. Juveniles were in the catch, which meant the fish were already reproducing in the reservoir. The department's spring 2005 Green River Region newsletter put it plainly: "This is really bad news." It predicted that walleye would eat the stocked rainbow and Bear River cutthroat faster than stocking could replace them, and that "ultimately the trout will disappear."
Twenty-two years later, the trout are still there, and other species have joined them. In its spring and summer 2026 outlook, Game and Fish called Sulphur Creek "another fishery on the upswing" and told anglers to expect kokanee salmon of 17 to 20 inches during 2026. Those kokanee are swimming in a reservoir 10.75 miles southeast of Evanston, and the coming ice season is the first one since that forecast came out.
Most people in town think of Sulphur Creek as a fishing spot, but it is also part of the city's water system. A 2022 Wyoming Water Development Commission survey lists Sulphur Creek Reservoir alongside the Bear River as Evanston's municipal surface-water sources. According to a Wyoming Game and Fish administrative report, the City of Evanston owns and operates the reservoir and maintains the roads, parking, restrooms and picnic shelters at the boat-ramp area.
That same report describes two ways in. For the south access, with its two boat ramps, take Highway 150 southeast for 10.75 miles, then turn onto County Road 173, also called Piedmont Road, for 1.2 miles. For shore access at the northwest corner of the dam, take Highway 150 for 9.5 miles, then County Road 75 for one mile. There is parking at the dam but no ramp.
Ice fishing here goes back a long way. A state water-planning memo from July 2000 called Sulphur Creek a popular winter ice-fishing location and noted that it had hosted the annual Lions Club Ice Fishing Derby for several years by then. The walleye turned up four years after that memo was written.
The 2004 newsletter warned that the problem could reach well past one reservoir. Biologists expected walleye to escape downstream and establish populations elsewhere in the Bear River drainage, naming Woodruff Reservoir and Bear Lake.
By spring 2006, the department said its biologists were assessing chemical restoration for the reservoir. That same year it set a liberal walleye limit to get anglers to take out as many fish as they legally could. The newsletter asked anglers for help controlling the population and pointed out that walleye "are excellent table fare."
The walleye never left. The department's 2026 fishing outlook says they are still in the reservoir and that early spring is a prime time to fish for them in shallow water during the spawn.
The 2004 newsletter assumed that stocking at the old rates couldn't keep a trout fishery going against walleye. The stocking records for the last three years show a much bigger program, with four species going in instead of two. These figures are Wyoming Game and Fish stocking records as compiled by Stocking Record, covering 2024 through June 2026:
| Species | 2024 | 2025 | 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kokanee | 16,071 | 16,396 | 15,367 |
| Cutthroat trout | none listed | 28,114 | 16,500 |
| Brown trout | 16,337 | 14,904 | 14,740 |
| Tiger trout | 21,686 | 13,556 | 15,000 |
| Total | 54,094 | 72,970 | 61,607 |
Most of these fish were small when they went in. In 2024 the kokanee averaged 2.8 inches and the tiger trout 3 to 6.2 inches, and the September 2024 brown trout averaged 8.6 inches. The latest release on record was 15,000 tiger trout in June 2026, averaging 4.1 inches.
The kokanee are the clearest growth story. The fish stocked in May and June 2024 were under 3 inches long. When Game and Fish sampled the reservoir in spring 2025, the kokanee measured 13 to 16 inches. That is why the department expects 17-to-20-inch kokanee in 2026, along with a younger class in the 13-to-16-inch range. The outlook says the reservoir went through "a few slower seasons during stocking adjustments" and is now expected to produce solid fishing.
On January 12, 2026, Game and Fish announced that the Sulphur Creek Fishing Derby would not be held, and neither would the Kemmerer Lions Club Fishing Derby at Viva Naughton Reservoir. The Burbot Bash at Flaming Gorge was cancelled too. John Walrath, the department's Green River Region fisheries supervisor, said it "has been an unusually warm winter, and ice conditions across southwest Wyoming have been inconsistent and unsafe."
So the kokanee that measured 13 to 16 inches in spring 2025 went through last winter without a derby on Sulphur Creek. If this winter brings safe ice, it will be the first ice season on the reservoir since the department forecast 17-to-20-inch kokanee for 2026. Game and Fish's derby announcement noted that derby cancellations are up to the planning organizations, and it encourages anglers to check ahead that an event is still on as scheduled. The Burbot Bash has already put a date on the calendar for this season, tentatively January 22 through 24, 2027, at Flaming Gorge.
Sulphur Creek is the reservoir closest to town on the south side, but there are good options in other directions. Woodruff Narrows Reservoir sits 12 miles north of Evanston by Highway 89 and County Road 101. It holds Bear River cutthroat trout and yellow perch, and Game and Fish notes that its access roads and parking areas are not plowed in winter. Woodruff is also the water the 2004 newsletter worried the walleye might reach.
Farther out, Viva Naughton Reservoir near Kemmerer is on a similar comeback. Game and Fish adjusted its rainbow trout stocking there and expects rainbows over 20 inches in 2026, and the area has been producing state-record tiger trout, with the latest caught just below the reservoir. For moving water, our fall look at the Bear River above Evanston covers the river side of the same drainage, and our guide to Evanston's winter recreation covers the days when the wind keeps everyone off the ice.
When the 2004 crew pulled walleye from the nets at the dam, Game and Fish expected the trout to disappear from Sulphur Creek. In 2026 the same city-owned reservoir, 10.75 miles down Highway 150, took in cutthroat, browns, tiger trout and kokanee, and the department forecast kokanee of 17 to 20 inches.
If you pull a big kokanee through the ice at Sulphur Creek this winter, Britany Erickson would love to see the picture. Text or call Britany at (307) 799-8096 to share it.
Deciding Whether to Sell Your Home As-Is or Make Upgrades in Evanston, WY.
What Happens After You Accept an Offer in Evanston, WY: Your Path to Closing Day.
Smart Home Updates for Selling in Evanston, WY, and Winning Strong Offers.
Experience seamless real estate transactions with Britany Erickson. From buying to selling, Britany's commitment to exceptional service ensures a successful outcome. Trust in her local knowledge and expertise to simplify your real estate journey and maximize the value of your investment.